No, it really wouldn't. You'd end up right where you are at this moment. Ford saying "he did it", Kavanaugh saying "no I didn't", and the other people Ford listed as witnesses saying "I don't remember ever being at a party with those people."
Murkowski losing her spine is a bad sign, although there is a high-profile sexual assault case that's occupying headlines in Alaska right now.
Collins is the key. If you get her, you can lose Murkowski. And I don't think Murkowski would want to be the vote that sinks Kavanaugh.