Trump’s proposed peace deal in the Israel-Gaza war looks decent By Andrea Widburg

[mystery-ak]

September 28, 2025
Trump’s proposed peace deal in the Israel-Gaza war looks decent
By Andrea Widburg

In a just world, Israel would completely defeat Hamas, just as the Allies defeated Nazi Germany. After all, Hamas is as antisemitic and genocidally inclined as Nazi Germany, and if the world paid attention, people would see that it also has dreams of a Thousand-Year Caliphate with complete world domination. But the world is stupid, and too many nations have thrown their weight behind the death cult. Israel is fighting extraordinarily well, but it could use an off-ramp, and Trump may have provided one.

You’ve probably heard Trump saying that he has a peace deal that may work, and he may be right—in large part because the proposed deal forces Qatar, which has been funding Hamas and sheltering its leaders, to buy in. It also provides certain guarantees to the people in Gaza, which may see them turn on Hamas if they feel it’s depriving them of an opportunity that doesn’t involve living as permanent refugees in some other Arab nation (which they won’t like).

As for Israel, it gives a little and gets a little...and mostly gets its surviving hostages back, plus some breathing space from an insanely hostile world. Fiercely pro-Israel people—located in Israel—whom I follow on social media seem to feel that this is a viable plan. And given that Netanyahu works closely with Trump, it seems reasonable to assume that the Israeli government has already given Trump the go-ahead on this plan.

more
https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2025/09/trump_s_proposed_peace_deal_in_the_israel_gaza_war_looks_decent.html

[Kamaji]

And when HAmas inevitably breaks the deal, will there be any consequences?

[berdie]

And when HAmas inevitably breaks the deal, will there be any consequences?

From what I heard at the televised presser...if Hamas doesn't comply Israel can go back in with our complete backing.

But since at the time of the presser, Hamas still hadn't agreed to jack squat it is somewhat of a moot point. They say they haven't received the written agreement. 

[Right_in_Virginia]

But since at the time of the presser, Hamas still hadn't agreed to jack squat it is somewhat of a moot point. They say they haven't received the written agreement. 

Representatives from Qatar and Egypt have delivered the proposal to Hamas -- not long after the end of the POTUS/Netanyahu presser. @berdie

[Kamaji]

From what I heard at the televised presser...if Hamas doesn't comply Israel can go back in with our complete backing.

But since at the time of the presser, Hamas still hadn't agreed to jack squat it is somewhat of a moot point. They say they haven't received the written agreement. 

Let’s be honest here:  when Hamas breaks the deal, there won’t be any consequences, and Israel will once again be beset by the haters when it tries to defend itself.

[berdie]

Representatives from Qatar and Egypt have delivered the proposal to Hamas -- not long after the end of the POTUS/Netanyahu presser. @berdie

That's great @Right_in_Virginia. But the point I was trying to make is that is no agreement from Hamas as of today.

[Right_in_Virginia]

That's great @Right_in_Virginia. But the point I was trying to make is that is no agreement from Hamas as of today.

Technically, there's no agreement from anyone without signatures @berdie   

I was simply giving an update that Hamas has received a copy of the peace proposal since the presser.

[berdie]

Let’s be honest here:  when Hamas breaks the deal, there won’t be any consequences, and Israel will once again be beset by the haters when it tries to defend itself.

If they can get the hostages released (big if) that would be a huge gain. I think politics in Israel will ease up and even be more aggressive when the fighting starts again.

It's a given that Hamas will break the deal...it's also a given that Israel will be the bad guys when the fighting restarts. But they are the bad guys no matter what.

[berdie]

Technically, there's no agreement from anyone without signatures @berdie   

I was simply giving an update that Hamas has received a copy of the peace proposal since the presser.

That's what I deemed from the presser when no questions were taken from the press. I think Trump kinda shut that down which is odd. He must be afraid of  derailing any agreements. @Right_in-Virginia

[Hoodat]

Can anyone remember a single time in the past 38 years where Hamas told the truth?

[GtHawk]

Can anyone remember a single time in the past 38 years where Hamas told the truth?

When they said they wanted to kill every single Jew?

[Cyber Liberty]

The history of Israel is littered with the broken "promises" of animalstineans.  If there ends up being a deal to end hostilities, it will be broken before the ink dries.  Everybody knows hostages will not be released.  Peace can't happen until every Hamas is wiped out. 

Sad, but it's true that Israel will be blamed for what's coming.