Federal Judge Throws Out Puerto Rico Climate Lawsuit As Nationwide Climate Dismissals Pile Up
Plaintiffs’ attempt to hold energy companies accountable under RICO fails, marking yet another setback for a failed legal 'theory'.
by Kyle Kohli September 15, 2025, 9:34 AM in Extreme Weather, Lawfare, Money & Finance, News and Opinion,
Two years after The New York Times ran a feature story on the private attorney representing Puerto Rico municipalities in their climate lawsuit, a federal judge has dismissed the case. [emphasis, links added]
When the case was filed, the outlet wrote that attorney Missy Sims is “the singular force behind a creative legal gambit to make oil and gas companies pay” for the [alleged] effects of climate change.
This “gambit,” which included charging oil companies under anti-racketeering laws for the first time, generated many a headline but ultimately ended the same way as many other cases against the industry: dismissal.
https://climatechangedispatch.com/puerto-rico-climate-lawsuit-dismissal-energy-companies/