Author Topic: Looking Back, Looking Forward: The Enduring Lessons of Security Force Assistance  (Read 118 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

rangerrebew

  • Guest
Looking Back, Looking Forward: The Enduring Lessons of Security Force Assistance

Shawna Sinnott and Andrew Milburn | 01.28.22
Looking Back, Looking Forward: The Enduring Lessons of Security Force Assistance

What is the role of security force assistance in achieving national security objectives? Where did security force assistance work well in the post-9/11 era, and where was it unsuccessful? How did policy considerations differ from tactical implementation? And most importantly, how can research and experience from the past twenty years of war inform ongoing partner-building activities in a decidedly different Indo-Pacific theater?

Episode 45 of the Irregular Warfare Podcast engages with these motivating questions by drawing on the extensive practical experience and award-winning research of our guests, who begin by establishing the nature of security force assistance operations in the current security landscape. They reflect on the lessons of the United States in Afghanistan and Iraq, while also identifying how other states have succeeded and failed in security force assistance operations. Our guests then consider whether these findings are applicable to the United States’ current focus in the Indo-Pacific theater, where partner force training and development has taken on a new urgency in light of a growing China, or if the contemporary environment in fact has distinct characteristics when it comes to partner compliance.

Retired Lieutenant General Larry Nicholson served for almost forty years in the United States Marine Corps, during which time he commanded the 1st Marine Division and the 2nd Marine Expeditionary Brigade / Task Force Leatherneck, Afghanistan. Most recently he served as commanding general of III Marine Expeditionary Force, leading thirty thousand Marines and sailors in the Asia-Pacific region, before retiring in 2018.

https://mwi.usma.edu/looking-back-looking-forward-the-enduring-lessons-of-security-force-assistance/

Offline AARguy

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 461
Trying to assist indigenous armies in the Middle East to fight a war is akin to trying to help a three year old rebuild the engine of a 57 Chevy. It just cant be done. I helped train the NEW Iraqi Army after the defeat of Sadaam. There was no feeling of nationalism among the recruits. Their ties were to Islam, their families and their extended families/community. They had no motivation to defend their country. Upon graduation of the First Battalion in October 2003, when they found out they might not be stationed in their home towns, there was a peaceful sit-down revolt. It took the "locked and loaded" guns of the 1/10th Cavalry to control them.

So understand that such assistance is not just a matter of the TRAINING... its a matter of the motivation of the trainees. And all the money in the world cannot turn an unmotivated recruit into a battle ready hero.

I hope we do better in the Pacific. And for the folks that live there, I hope they do too.