The problem here, I think, is one of definition. The headline says "retirement homes," but the article itself says "nursing homes."
Nursing homes, where a patient with serious medical issues is confined -- ok, I get it. No one wants to have people bring in the virus to these weakened patients.
But what is a "retirement home?" Is Trump also referring to retirement communities with healthy, active age 55+ residents? I think that's a bit extreme.
There's a brand new facility not far from me. It has a nursing and personal care facility, plus a set of cottages for those 55 and older in good health. Why should those in the cottages be so restricted?
Much of our problem here has to do with poor communication. We ordinary folks need clarity; we need definitions. We aren't getting those things.