Author Topic: Take It from a European: NATO Is Obsolete  (Read 416 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

rangerrebew

  • Guest
Take It from a European: NATO Is Obsolete
« on: February 23, 2017, 12:13:15 pm »

Take It from a European: NATO Is Obsolete
Polish Leopard II during Exercise Steadfast Jazz 2013. Flickr/U.S. Army Europe
Tom Sauer

The recent visit by Secretary of Defense James Mattis to NATO allies does not erase the fact that, as a presidential candidate and president-elect, Donald Trump stated on many occasions that NATO is obsolete. It is a bigger problem than just burden sharing. Trump’s key message is that the world has changed to the detriment of the United States, and that NATO no longer fits comfortably into this new world order. Of course, the United States will not withdraw from the organization, but NATO will get less attention from the Oval Office in the coming years. That is for sure.

For those in Europe who care about the alliance, this is a nightmare. But instead of clinging to the past, they should wake up. The world today is indeed fundamentally different from the one we happen to know, and certainly from the times into which NATO was born. It is indeed bizarre that NATO is still alive. Defense alliances are, by definition, temporary. Realists do not believe in long-term structural cooperation between states, and certainly not in the field of security. At most, states can try to cooperate in an alliance on a short-term basis to defeat a common enemy, like during the two world wars and during the Cold War. Once the enemy is gone, alliances have no meaning anymore. It was on this basis that John Mearsheimer and many others predicted the end of the alliance after the end of the Cold War. The implosion of the Warsaw Pact and the USSR itself should, indeed, have led to the demise of NATO.

 
Source URL (retrieved on February 23, 2017): http://nationalinterest.org/feature/take-it-european-nato-obsolete-19537