Some argue the Navy should consider updating conventionally powered carriers or expanding the fleet of more versatile and cost-effective America-class amphibious assault ships ...
I do not know who Peter Suciu is and what qualifications he has, if any, but he seems unaware that the USN has not commissioned a conventionally powered carrier since 1968, and that the last such carrier, USS Kitty Hawk, was decommissioned in 2009. So the USN has no conventionally powered carriers to update. What Suciu has against nuclear power and why Suciu wants USN carriers to be tethered again to an oil tanker fleet, I do not know.
Peter Suciu also seems unaware that two America class LHAs are under construction (and two already in commission), one expected to be commissioned in 2025, and a third has been authorized, though not yet laid down. He also seems unaware of the 7 Wasp class LHDs currently in commission, which can up to 20 F-35s and 6 ASW helicopters. IOW, Suciu ignored both the fact that the USN
is expanding its fleet of America class LHAs and an entire, in-commission, class of ships of similar capability.
Suciu seems to have much more agenda than actual relevant knowledge.