My preferences, I think Jif natural with honey in it but generally, when it is on special only. Skippy has a natural too, I have one right here but no honey in it.
Otherwise, usually what's on special. I know this lady who for some reason is picky about Fisher's Peanut Butter and you have to hunt for that. One of our stores carries it. I know they use it to cook some cookies.

I do like the ones with honey and will buy the Smucker's Peanut Butter and Jelly from time to time too. Must be when I really have a sweet tooth.