http://www.nytimes.com/2015/10/11/opinion/sunday/the-republicans-ugly-revolt.html?ref=opinion&_r=0The Republicans’ Ugly Revolt
OCT. 10, 2015
OVER the last two decades, through Bob Dole and George W. Bush and John McCain and Mitt Romney, it has become an article of faith that the Republican presidential nominee is a person blessed by, or acceptable to, the party’s establishment, meaning the elders, the bankers, the cool heads, the deep pockets.
There’s mess along the way — brief tantrums by restive voters, fleeting triumphs by renegade candidates — but order and obeisance in the end.
Is this the election cycle when that changes?
The twilight of the Republican elite?
Donald Trump’s stamina and the ascendance of Ben Carson and Carly Fiorina suggest as much. The three of them, who have led national polls since mid-September, aren’t just political outsiders, which is the label hung on them most frequently. They’re instruments of protest by Republican voters unwilling to heed the prompts and protocol that they’re expected to.
For Republicans (and perhaps for Democrats, too) this is a season of rebellion, as the chaos in the House of Representatives vividly illustrates. A consequential share of the Republican majority there have made it clear that they will not bow to precedent, not follow any conventional script, not have anyone foisted on them. No, they’ll do the foisting themselves.
Glenn Thrush of Politico captured this dynamic in an article following the withdrawal of Representative Kevin McCarthy from the race to be the next speaker of the House. Enumerating the reasons no sane person would seek the job, Thrush wrote that “if you have any chance of winning, you’re automatically the ‘establishment,’ ” and you’re thus anathema to a group of bomb throwers in the Republican caucus who are “leery of anybody who followed the preordained lines of succession.”
Those bomb throwers are mirrors of the voters who are saying no to Jeb Bush, no to Chris Christie, no to John Kasich, no to anyone who was once or could soon be the darling of the northeastern Acela corridor.
And they’re pointing the Republican primary in a genuinely unpredictable direction.
This isn’t a mere replay of four years ago, when Michele Bachmann, Herman Cain and Rick Santorum had their moments. They were middle fingers raised one at a time, in succession (even if Santorum was really more a pinkie). Trump, Carson and Fiorina are parallel, simultaneous phenomena, constituting a gesture of more profound rebuke.
continued
