The Briefing Room

General Category => National/Breaking News => SCOTUS News => Topic started by: libertybele on February 09, 2024, 01:34:35 am

Title: Supreme Court had 'perfectly glacial' reception to Trump ballot removal arguments, Jonathan Turley s
Post by: libertybele on February 09, 2024, 01:34:35 am
Supreme Court had 'perfectly glacial' reception to Trump ballot removal arguments, Jonathan Turley says

Fox News contributor Jonathan Turley detailed how the Supreme Court had a "perfectly glacial" reception to the Trump ballot removal arguments presented on Thursday, arguing the left-leaning justices were the ones asking the tough questions as the 2024 election hangs in the balance. Turley gave his firsthand analysis of the oral arguments during "Outnumbered," as deliberations concerning the 14th Amendment continue.

JONATHAN TURLEY: I think that the advocates for disqualification probably expected a cold reception, but this was perfectly glacial… The problem for [attorney] Jason Murray is that his toughest questions came from the left of the court. Many people have been saying how the conservatives are going to sandbag this entire appeal, and how they have to look deeply within themselves. Many of the toughest questions were coming from Justice Jackson and Justice Kagan, and Justice Jackson notably kept on raising this first question, which is, perhaps the presidency is just not covered by this provision. ............


https://www.foxnews.com/media/supreme-court-perfectly-glacial-reception-trump-ballot-removal-arguments-jonathan-turley
Title: Re: Supreme Court had 'perfectly glacial' reception to Trump ballot removal arguments, Jonathan Turl
Post by: Free Vulcan on February 09, 2024, 03:36:06 am
If the SCOTUS sides against Trump here the Pandora's box of anarchy that this will open up will just rip everything apart as we know it.
Title: Re: Supreme Court had 'perfectly glacial' reception to Trump ballot removal arguments, Jonathan Turl
Post by: libertybele on February 09, 2024, 03:46:38 am
If the SCOTUS sides against Trump here the Pandora's box of anarchy that this will open up will just rip everything apart as we know it.

I agree with you and I hope not but I'm not holding my breath.
Title: Re: Supreme Court had 'perfectly glacial' reception to Trump ballot removal arguments, Jonathan Turl
Post by: Maj. Bill Martin on February 09, 2024, 05:33:58 am
Slam dunk.  Those of us who predicted 7-2 in favor of Trump may have been pessimistic.  Could be 8-1 or even 9-0.

But he won't win that immunity case.
Title: Re: Supreme Court had 'perfectly glacial' reception to Trump ballot removal arguments, Jonathan Turl
Post by: PeteS in CA on February 09, 2024, 05:34:00 pm
Slam dunk.  Those of us who predicted 7-2 in favor of Trump may have been pessimistic.  Could be 8-1 or even 9-0.

But he won't win that immunity case.

The American Center for Law and Justice people, who represent the Colorado R Party, were speculating about the possibility of a 9-0 decision.

The whole 14th Amendment shtick is multi-layer compounded absurdity. Hopefully the USSC crushes the whole idea that a state can deny a candidate due process and exclude him/her for something vanishingly trivial (compared to a 4 year war in which 2/3 of a million men died).
Title: Re: Supreme Court had 'perfectly glacial' reception to Trump ballot removal arguments, Jonathan Turl
Post by: Bigun on February 09, 2024, 06:33:55 pm
The American Center for Law and Justice people, who represent the Colorado R Party, were speculating about the possibility of a 9-0 decision.

The whole 14th Amendment shtick is multi-layer compounded absurdity. Hopefully the USSC crushes the whole idea that a state can deny a candidate due process and exclude him/her for something vanishingly trivial (compared to a 4 year war in which 2/3 of a million men died).

When we saw rookie lawyers instead of well experienced ones presenting the Colorado case we knew it was over before it started.