The Briefing Room

General Category => World News => Topic started by: mystery-ak on March 04, 2014, 02:07:08 pm

Title: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: mystery-ak on March 04, 2014, 02:07:08 pm
http://www.newsmax.com/PrintTemplate.aspx?nodeid=555860 (http://www.newsmax.com/PrintTemplate.aspx?nodeid=555860)


Newsmax
Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Tuesday, March 4, 2014 06:53 AM

By: REUTERS

President Vladimir Putin said on Tuesday that Russia saw no need to use military force in the Crimea region of Ukraine for now, in remarks apparently intended to ease East-West tension over fears of war in the former Soviet republic.

The use of force by Russia in Ukraine would be a choice of last resort, Putin said, and sanctions being considered against Moscow by the West would be counter-productive.

Putin told a news conference at his state residence outside Moscow there had been an "unconstitutional coup" in Ukraine and ousted leader Viktor Yanukovich, an ally of Russia, was still the legitimate leader of the country despite giving up all power.

Earlier on Tuesday, Putin ordered troops involved in a military exercise in western Russia, close to the border with Ukraine, back to their bases.

Russian financial markets rebounded after sharp falls on Monday, and the euro and dollar rose in Japan, though Moscow's forces remained in control of Ukraine's Crimea region, seized bloodlessly after Yanukovich was ousted last month.

Russia paid a heavy financial price on Monday for its military intervention in Ukraine, with stocks, bonds and the rouble plunging as Putin's forces tightened their grip in Crimea, whose population is mainly ethnic Russian.

The Moscow stock market fell more than 10 percent on Monday, wiping nearly $60 billion off the value of Russian firms, but Russian stock indexes rose more than 4 percent early on Tuesday before slipping back again slightly, though still up on the day.

Putin said the turmoil in Russian markets was a "tactical, temporary" decision by investors.

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry will propose ways for a negotiation between Russia and Ukraine to be overseen by a multilateral organization when he visits Kiev on Tuesday.

NATO allies will hold emergency talks on the crisis on Tuesday, for the second time in three days.

In further pressure on Kiev, Russia's top gas producer Gazprom said it would remove a discount on gas prices for Ukraine from April, Interfax news agency cited the company's chief as saying on Tuesday.

However, Gazprom chief Alexei Miller also said the company could offer Ukraine a loan of $2-3 billion to pay off the country's debt of more than $1.5 billion after Ukraine said it was unable to pay in full for gas deliveries in February, Interfax news agency said.

Putin said at the weekend that he had the right to invade Ukraine to protect Russian interests and citizens after Yanukovich's downfall following months of popular unrest. Russia's Black Sea Fleet has a base in Crimea.

But the military exercises in central and western Russia, which began last week and raised fears that Russia might send forces to Russian-speaking regions of east Ukraine, were completed on schedule.

"The supreme commander of the armed forces of the Russian Federation, Vladimir Putin, gave the order for the troops and units, taking part in the military exercises, to return to their bases," Kremlin spokesman Dmitry Peskov was quoted as saying by Russian news agencies.

Although the end of the exercises had been planned, the announcement sent a more conciliatory message than much of the rhetoric from Russian officials, who say Moscow must defend national interests and those of compatriots in Ukraine.

Putin is dismayed that the new leadership in Ukraine, the cradle of Russian civilization, has plotted a course towards the European Union and away from what had been Moscow's sphere of influence during generations of Soviet Communist rule.

Moscow's U.N. envoy told a stormy meeting of the Security Council that Yanukovich had sent a letter to Putin requesting he use Russia's military to restore law and order in Ukraine.

Ukraine said observers from the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe, a pan-European security body, would travel at its invitation to Crimea in an attempt to defuse the military standoff there.

The United States has begun spelling out its response to Russia's incursion, announcing a suspension of all military engagements with Russia, including military exercises and port visits, and freezing trade and investment talks with Moscow.

President Barack Obama met national security advisers on Monday to discuss how the United States and its allies could "further isolate" Russia, a White House official said.

"Over time this will be a costly proposition for Russia," Obama told reporters.

The State Department said the United States was preparing to impose sanctions on Russia, although no decisions had yet been made.

Members of the U.S. Congress are looking at options including sanctions on Russia's banks and freezing assets of Russian public institutions and private investors, but they said they wanted European states to step up their involvement.

A Kremlin aide said that if the United States did impose sanctions, Moscow might drop the dollar as a reserve currency and refuse to repay loans to U.S. banks.

An International Monetary Fund mission is in Kiev to discuss financial assistance for Ukraine to help it avoid bankruptcy. Kiev's new leaders want a financial package worth at least $15 billion, with a quick release of some of the cash.

The European Union has threatened unspecified "targeted measures" unless Russia returns its forces to their bases and opens talks with Ukraine's new government.

Western leaders have sent a barrage of warnings to Putin against armed action, threatening economic and diplomatic consequences, but are not considering a military response.

There was no immediate sign of any new movements by Russian forces in Crimea overnight although Ukraine's acting president said on Monday that Russia's military presence on the Black Sea peninsula was growing.

Ukrainian officials said Russia was building up armour on its side of the 4.5-km (2.7-mile) wide Kerch strait between the Crimean peninsula and southern Russia.

Russian forces shipped three truckloads of troops by ferry into Crimea after taking control of the border post on the Ukrainian side, Ukraine's border guards spokesman said.

Vladimir, a 50-year-old cab driver, said people do not want the Russians to leave.

"When they are here, it is safer," he said, voicing the opinions of some in the region who fear a return to the chaos in Ukraine after the collapse of the Soviet Union.

Kiev's U.N. ambassador, Yuriy Sergeyev, said Russia had deployed roughly 16,000 troops to Crimea since last week.

Both sides have avoided bloodshed, but the market turmoil on Monday highlighted damage the crisis could wreak on Russia's vulnerable economy, making it harder to balance the budget and potentially undermining business and public support for Putin.

EU foreign ministers held out the threat of sanctions if Moscow fails to withdraw its troops from Ukraine, while offering to mediate, alongside other international bodies.

EU leaders will hold an emergency summit on Thursday.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: mystery-ak on March 04, 2014, 03:54:09 pm
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-03-04/putin-says-no-need-yet-for-russia-to-send-troops-to-ukraine.html (http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-03-04/putin-says-no-need-yet-for-russia-to-send-troops-to-ukraine.html)

Putin Says No Immediate Need to Invade Eastern Ukraine, Leaves Threat Dangling
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 04, 2014, 03:55:38 pm
So long as the US and Western Europe continue to give Putin for free what he would otherwise have to obtain by force, then there's no need to use force, obviously.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: alicewonders on March 04, 2014, 04:04:32 pm
Putin is pretty much in the catbird seat right now.  He knows no one is going to stop him, so there is no impetus to have to use force. 
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 05:09:11 pm
Pooty-poot just blinked.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 05:12:21 pm
Putin is pretty much in the catbird seat right now.  He knows no one is going to stop him, so there is no impetus to have to use force.

Disagree.

No one may stop him militarily .... but Putin knows he's facing a world of financial hurt if the EU and US stand firm.
And from today's developments he apparently thinks they will.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: alicewonders on March 04, 2014, 05:19:14 pm
Disagree.

No one may stop him militarily .... but Putin knows he's facing a world of financial hurt if the EU and US stand firm.
And from today's developments he apparently thinks they will.

I don't think Putin blinked, I think he realizes if he does things in small steps, he won't have to use force and everyone will back down and eventually he reconstructs the old Soviet Union.  He is playing chess. 
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 05:22:58 pm
I don't think Putin blinked, I think he realizes if he does things in small steps, he won't have to use force and everyone will back down and eventually he reconstructs the old Soviet Union.  He is playing chess.

You don't know that.  Please stop portraying Putin as a mythical giant. 

He blinked.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 04, 2014, 05:25:53 pm
Disagree.

No one may stop him militarily .... but Putin knows he's facing a world of financial hurt if the EU and US stand firm.
And from today's developments he apparently thinks they will.

Maybe, maybe not.  Putin appears to be the master of the calibrated threat - getting what he wants degree by degree by keeping his threat level just below the point where he would incite a substantial reaction from the US or Europe.  He already has control over Crimea, so there isn't any real need to use military force there, and thus he's not giving away anything he already has by saying as much.  If he were to threaten the use of military force to immediately acquire more Ukrainian territory, he would almost certainly trigger a more robust reaction from the US and Europe, a response that could very well cause him to lose some or all of what he's already taken in Crimea.  Saying that he sees no need to use military force now simply lowers the level of tension, thereby easing the pressure on the US and Europe to act forcefully, making it more likely that he will keep what he already has even if he doesn't immediately gain more territory in Ukraine.

I could be wrong, but I would not be so quick to dismiss Putin as having blinked at this point.  Putin is the master of duplicity in geopolitical affairs - remember his oh-so-pious op-ed in the NYT during the Syria crisis precipitated by Obama?  He didn't mean a lick of that and yet he was taken seriously.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: alicewonders on March 04, 2014, 05:28:07 pm
You don't know that.  Please stop portraying Putin as a mythical giant. 

He blinked.

I guess time will tell.

I never portrayed Putin as a "mythical giant" - but compared to our own Obama - he is a jack-boot stepping on an ant.  Just something in the path.  Obama has reduced America to a weak and ineffectual laughing stock in the world.  He is the one that is a "mythical giant"..... to himself and to his followers. 
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Gazoo on March 04, 2014, 05:30:51 pm
I don't think Putin blinked, I think he realizes if he does things in small steps, he won't have to use force and everyone will back down and eventually he reconstructs the old Soviet Union.  He is playing chess.

Plus Kerry just promised the Ukraine money and probably gave Russia some to stfu until after midterms. Kerry probably said, after the elections you can do whatever you want.

Sound familiar?
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 04, 2014, 05:31:27 pm
You don't know that.  Please stop portraying Putin as a mythical giant. 

He blinked.

Please stop dismissing Putin so easily.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: alicewonders on March 04, 2014, 05:32:17 pm
Plus Kerry just promised the Ukraine money and probably gave Russia some to stfu until after midterms. Kerry probably said, after the elections you can do whatever you want.

Sound familiar?

Yep.   8888crybaby
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 05:43:42 pm

Obama has reduced America to a weak and ineffectual laughing stock in the world.   

I'm going to offer a provocative suggestion:  Let's stop helping the world laugh at us.  Maybe tone down the editorials, pundits, blogs, et al.  Mocking Obama is deserved and fun ... but we'd be smart to remember that, like it or not, laughing it up at Obama's expense is ultimately laughing it up at OUR expense. 

Politics stopping at the water's edge is a useful tradition.  I think we need to take a second look at it. 

Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 05:46:12 pm
Please stop dismissing Putin so easily.

I don't dismiss him at all. 

I simply refuse to turn him into an unstoppable god simply because he rides a horse shirtless.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 04, 2014, 05:51:11 pm
I don't dismiss him at all. 

I simply refuse to turn him into an unstoppable god simply because he rides a horse shirtless.

Fair enough, but your statements are as unqualified as those you're criticizing.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 05:52:21 pm
Fair enough, but your statements are as unqualified as those you're criticizing.

How so?
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 04, 2014, 05:56:06 pm
I'm going to offer a provocative suggestion:  Let's stop helping the world laugh at us.  Maybe tone down the editorials, pundits, blogs, et al.  Mocking Obama is deserved and fun ... but we'd be smart to remember that, like it or not, laughing it up at Obama's expense is ultimately laughing it up at OUR expense. 

Politics stopping at the water's edge is a useful tradition.  I think we need to take a second look at it. 



I really do not think the world will stop laughing at us if we simply shut up and let Obama do whatever it is he's going to do in silence.  The world is laughing at us because of what Obama has already done and, to the extent ordinary Americans have helped them to laugh, it was because of our stupidity in re-electing him, not anything we might say at this juncture.  In point of fact, given that the mood of ordinary appears to be in favor of much more aggressive action than Obama has said he is willing to take, the world should be more concerned about what the US might do, not less concerned, given our outspokenness.  Furthermore, outspokenness is something one should want more of, not less; were ordinary Russians more willing - and more able - to speak up the situation might be better than it is right now.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 04, 2014, 05:56:34 pm
How so?

"Putin blinked" is about as unqualified a statement as one will find on this thread.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Gazoo on March 04, 2014, 06:03:29 pm
I really do not think the world will stop laughing at us if we simply shut up and let Obama do whatever it is he's going to do in silence.  The world is laughing at us because of what Obama has already done and, to the extent ordinary Americans have helped them to laugh, it was because of our stupidity in re-electing him, not anything we might say at this juncture.  In point of fact, given that the mood of ordinary appears to be in favor of much more aggressive action than Obama has said he is willing to take, the world should be more concerned about what the US might do, not less concerned, given our outspokenness.  Furthermore, outspokenness is something one should want more of, not less; were ordinary Russians more willing - and more able - to speak up the situation might be better than it is right now.

 goopo
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: alicewonders on March 04, 2014, 06:06:13 pm
I'm going to offer a provocative suggestion:  Let's stop helping the world laugh at us.  Maybe tone down the editorials, pundits, blogs, et al.  Mocking Obama is deserved and fun ... but we'd be smart to remember that, like it or not, laughing it up at Obama's expense is ultimately laughing it up at OUR expense. 

Politics stopping at the water's edge is a useful tradition.  I think we need to take a second look at it.

Yes, let's not rock the boat or pile on Obama.  Let's not fight battles we know we can't win.  Where have I heard that before?  I don't believe it is in our best interest to do anything to keep Obama or his enablers in power for one minute more.  To say that Obama is taking this country down isn't just politics - it's the facts.  If we don't speak up now, we may never get a chance to again.  People have got to wake up to this and I for one, will go down kicking and screaming - not peeking out the crack in the curtains in a darkened room as I watch them take my neighbor away, afraid to speak up lest I will attract attention to myself.  To call attention to Obama's weakness is to take him down yet another notch, another inch closer to getting rid of him and his.  I don't get this whole mantra of "just hold off for NOW, we'll regain strength through silence".   
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 06:10:04 pm
"Putin blinked" is about as unqualified a statement as one will find on this thread.

Okay.  Valid point.  And I stand by it.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 04, 2014, 06:11:03 pm
Okay.  Valid point.  And I stand by it.

Fair enough; I'm happy to agree to disagree and see whom subsequent events vindicates.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 06:22:30 pm
I really do not think the world will stop laughing at us if we simply shut up and let Obama do whatever it is he's going to do in silence. 

Why do we have to help the world laugh at us?  Really, what happened to love of country over love of politics?

I am not now nor would I ever suggest, recommend, or hint at allowing Obama (or any president) to do whatever they want.  I'm all for Congress and the people taking a president to the woodshed.  But does it always have to be a public spectacle....feeding a global joke at our own expense?

I think the pundit and political class are going too far by actually helping to promote Obama (read:  the United States) as the world's clown.  This is not comic relief or political payback.  This is dangerous.   And, I say this as an American first.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 04, 2014, 06:32:04 pm
Why do we have to help the world laugh at us?  Really, what happened to love of country over love of politics?

I am not now nor would I ever suggest, recommend, or hint at allowing Obama (or any president) to do whatever they want.  I'm all for Congress and the people taking a president to the woodshed.  But does it always have to be a public spectacle....feeding a global joke at our own expense?

I think the pundit and political class are going too far by actually helping to promote Obama (read:  the United States) as the world's clown.  This is not comic relief or political payback.  This is dangerous.   And, I say this as an American first.

Yes, it does always have to be a "public spectacle" because if it isn't then it's nothing, it's simply sitting by silently and letting the president do what he pleases without criticism.  Freedom of speech, especially the freedom to criticise one's leaders, is always a "public spectacle" - that's why tyrants since time immemorial have attempted to suppress public criticism, precisely because it's public.

We made ourselves the laughing-stock that we are when we re-elected Obama; nothing else really matters because the real target of the world's ridicule is Obama's actions and his fecklessness, not the criticism we might voice.

Do you really think the world would find Obama's actions any the less deserving of ridicule if the American public simply stayed mum and said nothing?  i find that hard to believe.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Gazoo on March 04, 2014, 06:32:10 pm
Why do we have to help the world laugh at us?  Really, what happened to love of country over love of politics?

I am not now nor would I ever suggest, recommend, or hint at allowing Obama (or any president) to do whatever they want.  I'm all for Congress and the people taking a president to the woodshed.  But does it always have to be a public spectacle....feeding a global joke at our own expense?

I think the pundit and political class are going too far by actually helping to promote Obama (read:  the United States) as the world's clown.  This is not comic relief or political payback.  This is dangerous.   And, I say this as an American first.

The world, for the most part is Euro-Socialistic/marxist/communist and adored Obama. So what, if Obama and (marxist fascist socialism) is world wide seen for what it is. a joke! If we don't call it what it is then that is frightening. Because as an ex KGB-USSR spy said, after defecting to America-there is no where to go in fear of tyranny after America.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Rapunzel on March 04, 2014, 06:38:21 pm
BTW remember who we are dependent on to get to the space station - thanks to Obama.........
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 07:51:10 pm
So what, if Obama and (marxist fascist socialism) is world wide seen for what it is. a joke!
If we don't call it what it is then that is frightening. Because as an ex KGB-USSR spy said, after defecting to America-there is no where to go in fear of tyranny after America.

But "Marxists fascist socialism" is not seen as the joke.  The United States of America is seen as the joke. I am merely asking you to remember when this nation is viewed as a joke we are ALL vulnerable---very, very vulnerable.   And that's not funny at all.

As for the rest of your post .... well, I will admit I have no idea the point you're making.

But thanks.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 08:05:59 pm

Do you really think the world would find Obama's actions any the less deserving of ridicule if the American public simply stayed mum and said nothing?  i find that hard to believe.

Is this what you think I've been saying?
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Gazoo on March 04, 2014, 08:21:09 pm
But "Marxists fascist socialism" is not seen as the joke.  The United States of America is seen as the joke. I am merely asking you to remember when this nation is viewed as a joke we are ALL vulnerable---very, very vulnerable.   And that's not funny at all.

As for the rest of your post .... well, I will admit I have no idea the point you're making.

But thanks.

We are going to have to agree to disagree as it it obvious we are not understanding each other. As far as you not understanding the second part of my post. An ex KGB- USSR=communist- spook, defected to the US and this is what he had to say 29 years ago warning us.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3nXvScRazg (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3nXvScRazg)
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 04, 2014, 09:15:18 pm
We are going to have to agree to disagree

That's a given, dear.  And, again...thanks.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 05, 2014, 12:22:50 am
Is this what you think I've been saying?

That is what you have been saying.  How else am I, an ordinary private citizen, to express my disapproval of Obama and his conduct, other than publicly?  Shall I write him a nice letter - on paper even - and mail it to him?  Shall I send him an email?  Shall I telephone him?  Shall I instead telephone, mail, or email my Congressional representatives and ask them to express my disagreement to Obama?  And how shall I join with other like-minded people to voice our collective criticism of Obama?  Shall we meet in secret?

Except for a so-called "existential situation" where the existence of the US, or of a truly vital US interest, is at stake, I will not simply stand with the president no matter how much I might disagree with him or her simply because he or she is the president.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 05, 2014, 02:03:32 am
That is what you have been saying.  How else am I, an ordinary private citizen, to express my disapproval of Obama and his conduct, other than publicly?  Shall I write him a nice letter - on paper even - and mail it to him?  Shall I send him an email?  Shall I telephone him?  Shall I instead telephone, mail, or email my Congressional representatives and ask them to express my disagreement to Obama?  And how shall I join with other like-minded people to voice our collective criticism of Obama?  Shall we meet in secret? 

I mentioned over and over again that pundits and politicians taking to the airwaves and publically ridiculing (not just disagreeing with) Obama is not helpful.  It is hurting this nation and her citizens in ways that cannot be qualified. 

I'm all for expressing "disapproval" of any president, but I would like our political leaders to do more.  I'd like them to offer a different strategy to the president and the American people -- if only so Putin and his ilk know despite Obama we are still here...we are still strong ...and that will not change.  We need to demand this from our representatives.  Yes, phone calls, emails, letters are all in play.  And no, secrecy will not help.

The comedy skits I've been watching all over the airwaves are destructive.  There has to be something left standing if we are to survive this regime.  Now is the time for serious opposition with serious alternatives.  Now is the time to neuter this President--not with ridicule which feeds our enemies --- but with a clear and different strategy---one that will earn the vocal support of the American people.

The comic relief can come later.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: EC on March 05, 2014, 02:09:21 am
RiV - I respectfully disagree.

Comedy first. Get the ridicule firmly lodged in the average voters mind, then immediately follow up with practical and well thought out solutions. Think of the comedy as a bombardment before an attack (if you like WW1 metaphors).

But you are right. Conservatives can't just point and laugh, they need actual ways to solve the problem.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: alicewonders on March 05, 2014, 02:33:28 am
Mockery is a classic tactic of the left, used mercilessly to destroy those on our side that they most fear.  I want to see Obama mocked so severely, absolutely without an iota of mercy, until even the morons that voted for him are embarassed to admit it. 

He's down now, we must not go weak - we must keep our boot on his neck until he rolls his little bony ass into a fetal position from which he cannot stand up from!  Yes, it makes us look stupid too, BUT WE ARE!  The media has got to feel the heat from this too - they have got to be made to look in the camera and gulp hard, knowing they are going to have to try to make him look at least substandard. 

Listen, the rest of the world already knows what a complete mess his foreign policy is - the best we can hope for is to neuter him for the next three years and hope we can get a good clean-up guy in after that.  That's the best we can do at this point.  It's going to be hard to watch, but this guy's gotta fall - and he's got to fall HARD!
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 05, 2014, 03:28:37 am
I mentioned over and over again that pundits and politicians taking to the airwaves and publically ridiculing (not just disagreeing with) Obama is not helpful.  It is hurting this nation and her citizens in ways that cannot be qualified. 

I'm all for expressing "disapproval" of any president, but I would like our political leaders to do more.  I'd like them to offer a different strategy to the president and the American people -- if only so Putin and his ilk know despite Obama we are still here...we are still strong ...and that will not change.  We need to demand this from our representatives.  Yes, phone calls, emails, letters are all in play.  And no, secrecy will not help.

The comedy skits I've been watching all over the airwaves are destructive.  There has to be something left standing if we are to survive this regime.  Now is the time for serious opposition with serious alternatives.  Now is the time to neuter this President--not with ridicule which feeds our enemies --- but with a clear and different strategy---one that will earn the vocal support of the American people.

The comic relief can come later.

Standing comes, or goes, based on the leader and his actions, not on what the people - including the mass media - have to say.  Ronald Reagan managed to be quite effective, notwithstanding the comedic relief

(http://www.fybertech.com/4get/13590849402234.gif)


(http://www.cartoonstock.com/newscartoons/cartoonists/cma/lowres/military-presidents-nuclear_weapons-weapon-bomb-ronald_reagan-cman441l.jpg)


It's about the leader, not about the peanut gallery
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 05, 2014, 03:29:18 am
RiV - I respectfully disagree.

Comedy first. Get the ridicule firmly lodged in the average voters mind, then immediately follow up with practical and well thought out solutions. Think of the comedy as a bombardment before an attack (if you like WW1 metaphors).

But you are right. Conservatives can't just point and laugh, they need actual ways to solve the problem.

But liberals can?
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 05, 2014, 03:37:24 am
Mockery is a classic tactic of the left, used mercilessly to destroy those on our side that they most fear.  I want to see Obama mocked so severely, absolutely without an iota of mercy, until even the morons that voted for him are embarassed to admit it.

Mockery, while a political weapon that has its place, will empower Putin-- not stop him from replacing us in the world order.



Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 05, 2014, 03:38:41 am
Standing comes, or goes, based on the leader and his actions, not on what the people - including the mass media - have to say.  Ronald Reagan managed to be quite effective, notwithstanding the comedic relief

It's about the leader, not about the peanut gallery

How do we stop Putin?
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Rapunzel on March 05, 2014, 03:45:21 am
How do we stop Putin?

Their economy.  IF we had a president so inclined (I don't think we do) and a Europe so inclined (we don't)..... all they have is their oil and natural gas sales. Europe not wanting to be dependent on the ME went against Reagan and agreed to the pipelines from Russia to Europe making Europe dependent on Russia for Oil and gas. Poland is now fracking and is closer to Europe anyway.. help Poland get their fracking really going and pipelines built.......

However........  if I was Poland I would be really worried Russia will come for me to keep me from doing what I suggested, but they are part of NATO...

All in all Obama does not know how to play chess, Bush wrongly trusted Putin and he has played us and the world like a fine guitar.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: alicewonders on March 05, 2014, 04:08:00 am
How do we stop Putin?

I'm not sure that we can stop Putin right now.  We're not really strong enough and we don't have the capable leadership to pull it off.  I don't think Europe has the wherewithall to help either, they've been flailing too.  Putin is an opportunist and he sees an opening.  As far as making America look weak.........................it's too late.  We are weakened and from my view America is on her last legs.  We'll see what happens in the elections this year, but I'm frankly pessimistic.  We are desperate for leadership.  Who will be able to step up to that plate?  I love America too, but that America is almost gone - the America we have now is not much to be proud of, I'm sad to say.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 05, 2014, 05:24:33 am
How do we stop Putin?

Put a hurtin' on his cronies.  Put a hurtin' on the Ruble and Russia's cash cow, it's petro exports.  Start by freezing the assets of wealthy Russians.  That will get their attention but fast and they will start to question their continued support of Putin if they cannot get to the assets they've squirreled overseas.  Replace the $15b Ukraine borrowed from Russia prior to the overthrow and let Ukraine reneg on that debt.  Russia and its banks end up holding worthless paper.  Provide bridge loans that will allow Ukraine to wean itself off the natural gas subsidies it's been getting from Russia.  Put a freeze on continued imports of natural gas from Russia.

Russia has already had to up the interest rate on its sovereign debt to keep the ruble from tanking, so there is plenty of room to push, and push hard, to make the rest of Russia squeal hard enough that Putin has to back off.

The WSJ, for one, has some interesting articles on these matters, from which I've cribbed.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 05, 2014, 12:10:26 pm
Thanks for your replies ... I too see economic hurt as a strong weapon here.

Let's hope the EU clicks into gear on this.

Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Lipstick on a Hillary on March 05, 2014, 01:34:39 pm

Do you really think the world would find Obama's actions any the less deserving of ridicule if the American public simply stayed mum and said nothing?  i find that hard to believe.


Is this what you think I've been saying?

I'm late to this thread, but that's exactly how I interpreted it, too.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Lipstick on a Hillary on March 05, 2014, 01:40:14 pm
Mockery is a classic tactic of the left, used mercilessly to destroy those on our side that they most fear.  I want to see Obama mocked so severely, absolutely without an iota of mercy, until even the morons that voted for him are embarassed to admit it. 

He's down now, we must not go weak - we must keep our boot on his neck until he rolls his little bony ass into a fetal position from which he cannot stand up from!  Yes, it makes us look stupid too, BUT WE ARE!  The media has got to feel the heat from this too - they have got to be made to look in the camera and gulp hard, knowing they are going to have to try to make him look at least substandard.

You mean like this?

(http://www.ijreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Screen-Shot-2014-03-04-at-7.18.26-PM.jpg) 
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Right_in_Virginia on March 05, 2014, 04:38:25 pm
I'm late to this thread, but that's exactly how I interpreted it, too.

Color me shocked. 
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: alicewonders on March 05, 2014, 05:03:48 pm
You mean like this?

(http://www.ijreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/03/Screen-Shot-2014-03-04-at-7.18.26-PM.jpg)

Yeah, like that!   :chairbang:

(http://www.blackcatantiques.com/obamaschoolpodium.jpg)
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: musiclady on March 05, 2014, 07:04:09 pm
I'm not sure that we can stop Putin right now.  We're not really strong enough and we don't have the capable leadership to pull it off.  I don't think Europe has the wherewithall to help either, they've been flailing too.  Putin is an opportunist and he sees an opening.  As far as making America look weak.........................it's too late.  We are weakened and from my view America is on her last legs.  We'll see what happens in the elections this year, but I'm frankly pessimistic.  We are desperate for leadership.  Who will be able to step up to that plate?  I love America too, but that America is almost gone - the America we have now is not much to be proud of, I'm sad to say.

 goopo
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: musiclady on March 05, 2014, 07:05:34 pm
Their economy.  IF we had a president so inclined (I don't think we do) and a Europe so inclined (we don't)..... all they have is their oil and natural gas sales. Europe not wanting to be dependent on the ME went against Reagan and agreed to the pipelines from Russia to Europe making Europe dependent on Russia for Oil and gas. Poland is now fracking and is closer to Europe anyway.. help Poland get their fracking really going and pipelines built.......

However........  if I was Poland I would be really worried Russia will come for me to keep me from doing what I suggested, but they are part of NATO...

All in all Obama does not know how to play chess, Bush wrongly trusted Putin and he has played us and the world like a fine guitar.

Slight correction....

Bush trusted Putin early in his first term, but learned by Putin's subsequent behavior that he couldn't be trusted.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 06, 2014, 02:46:16 am
Thanks for your replies ... I too see economic hurt as a strong weapon here.

Let's hope the EU clicks into gear on this.



That's about the only real solution now, but from what I've read it's also potentially a very powerful weapon if the will exists to use it.  any military action would, I think, have to be largely confined to quietly providing Ukraine with armaments and, possibly, giving them access to the military grade GPS if necessary.  Given that this is Russia we're dealing with, I don't even think a no-fly zone would be a realistic possibility.  All Putin would need to get Russians really riled up and ready to go would be video of a Russian helicopter or aircraft getting shot down over Crimea by a US or EU fighter or missile.  I think Putin would move very swiftly, very brutally, to complete the takeover of Ukraine, and possibly start menacing Poland, as a means of making the US/EU back off.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: EC on March 06, 2014, 03:02:38 am
Does anyone else find that "for now" rather concerning?
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Oceander on March 06, 2014, 03:30:30 am
Does anyone else find that "for now" rather concerning?

yes
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Rapunzel on March 06, 2014, 03:36:53 am
Shep Smith is in The Ukraine right now. Today he and crew went to Crimea. At first (he said) everything looked normal, then they went to the navy yard and Russia has taken over the navy yards and has all the non-Russian ships blocked in with Russian naval ships which are all over the place... and this is not where Russia was leasing a port.
Title: Re: Putin: No Need to Use Military Force in Ukraine for Now
Post by: Chieftain on March 06, 2014, 03:39:47 am
(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v645/SeniorChieftain/another-line.jpg)