Did I read your comment correctly if a dog does not hunt it is culled?
Our Setters breed have 3 bloodlines in the English Setter Hall of Fame
Every once in a while we get a dog that shows zero interest in hunting. Not once have we ever culled on.
The setter at my feet right now showed zero interest in hunting. He is the most lovable dog we have ever had, a true cuddle bug. Never did cross my mind to take him to the gravel pit because he did not hunt
Don't give a shit for papers and awards. I care that the dog does his job and don't go sideways too much.
A dog that gets in the chicken coop and slaughters all the birds will be dead the next day.
A dog that sucks eggs won't last long.
Any dog chasing livestock or deer will die. It's only a matter of time.
I have shot more than a few for that very infraction.
I say that having just lost my companion of seventeen years last spring - A small Aussie Shepherd that worked most of his life with livestock and was a grand help. And he never bothered the chickens, and made a fair peace with the barn cats. He wasn't much for guardian - too small of frame... But he'd work with the guard dogs, playing heeler as they came head on.
That was a hella good dog, ol Chewy was. But had he been otherwise he would be no more.