The Briefing Room
General Category => Health/Education => Life News => Topic started by: PeteS in CA on August 10, 2021, 12:18:51 am
-
After 6 years of litigation, Federal Court Permanently Enjoins ACA Abortion/Transgender Mandate
https://reason.com/volokh/2021/08/09/after-6-years-of-litigation-federal-court-permanently-enjoins-aca-abortion-transgender-mandate/ (https://reason.com/volokh/2021/08/09/after-6-years-of-litigation-federal-court-permanently-enjoins-aca-abortion-transgender-mandate/)
In 2016, HHS promulgated a mandate "requiring medical providers to perform and insure abortions and gender-transition procedures." Since then, the case has floated in regulatory limbo over the course of three presidential administrations. Today, the District Court entered a permanent injunction blocking the mandate.
Read the opinion the get the full history, which is too lengthy to summarize. Here is a brief summary of the RFRA argument:
Here, the RFRA violation, the success on the merits, is all but conceded. No party disputes that the current Section 1557 regulatory scheme threatens to burden Christian Plaintiffs' religious exercise in the same way as the 2016 scheme: namely, by placing substantial pressure on Christian Plaintiffs, in the form of fines and civil liability, to perform and provide insurance coverage for gender-transition procedures and abortions. Like before, the current scheme continues to fall short of the "more focused" RFRA inquiry. ...
...
The lack of briefing on this issue from the government, despite the Fifth Circuit's specific mandate, is concerning and speaks to, at best, the authenticity of HHS and the 2021 Interpretation's generalized promise to "comply with the Religious Freedom Restoration Act . . . and all other legal requirements," see 2021 Interpretation, and, at worst, may suggest some sort of religious animus in the failure to include reasonable religious exemptions in the formation and promulgation of the 2021 Interpretation.
This is the decision of the District Court. That the LIEden Administration will appeal this all the way to the USSC is pretty much certain.
-
Never forget that Republicans had the opportunity to overturn Obamacare, but they chose not to.