@Maj. Bill Martin
Gee,you think that MAYBE the stars on her collars had something to do with it? WHY would Trump think that a 4 star General Officer WASN'T competent?
@sneakypete That is a hell of a lot of backpedaling from saying the guy should be taken out and beaten almost to death multiple times. And they
all have stars on their collars, so justifying Trump's pick on that basis is ridiculous. The question is why did Trump choose that
particular general and his stars over any of the other choices he could have made. Why ignore the recommendation of both the Secretary of Defense and Chairman of the Joint Chiefs to pick someone else? Why Milley??
Trump had known Milley for more than
two years before he made that pick. And remember the debate during the Trump Administration over women in infantry/combat units? The Commandant of the Marine Corps, Dunford, had argued against it. Mattis had argued against it. But Milley was for it, and
that's who Trump chose. He met with the Joint Chiefs all the time -- he had a chance to hear their views on issues (including women in combat) for two years. He made his own evaluation, his own judgment, and is solely responsible for it.
The only conclusion I can come to is that Miss Miley was blowing a group of prominent politicians,and they were the ones that put the stars on her and suggested she be made the Top Dog.
No, that isn't the only conclusion you can come to. You can come to the correct conclusion -- the only one for which there is a shred of evidecce and that was openly reported at the time.
Trump struck up a good personal relationship with Milley, thought he was a really smart negotiator, and overruled the recommendations of the SecDef and CJS. There isn't a shred of evidence that some unnamed "politicians" recommended Milley instead, but if they did, what kind of an idiot with zero military experience of his own would choose to listen to a bunch of politicians rather than to guys with more more than 60 years of experience between them?
Milley is on Trump, and Trump
alone.