@LegalAmerican I have to be honest,here. Not only "No",but HELL NO!"
The typical soldier is about as familiar with weapons and shooting as is the typical child in kindergarten. They have seen a lot of it in movies,but know nothing about it personally.
The typical sailor is even worse and potentially more dangerous.
Restrict it to people in the combat arms branches or MP MOS's that actually handle weapons for a living,and I am in 100 percent agreement. Giving loaded handguns to the typical soldier or sailor is akin to handing them out to children. I know. I have actually tried to teach support branch active duty soldiers how to shoot on a range,and it can be pretty damn scary. Seems like there was ALWAYS at least one accidental discharge from some bozo pulling the trigger and then saying "I'm sorry,I thought the safety was on!",just like that was an excuse. WTH was the bozo pulling the trigger to start with,safety or no safety? The FIRST rule you teach them is to treat ALL guns as if they are loaded with a round in the chamber,and to KEEP YOUR FINGER OFF THE TRIGGER UNTIL YOU ARE READY TO SHOOT!
And these are soldiers who have been through basic training,and all are over 18 years old.
Also,it takes more than a little bit of experience to be able to hit what you are shooting at,and to understand the dynamics of shooting in reference to backgrounds,when to shoot and when NOT to shoot,not shooting at innocents or hitting innocents by mistake,etc,etc,etc. The typical support branch soldier gets to shoot his issued rifle once a year at the annual qualification,and never even sees it again until the next year.
Don't forget,most of the people of today get all their firearms and gunfight knowledge from movies and tv shows,and think guns are some sort of magic wands that never miss,and that "spray and pray" is a sound tactical idea. I have actually gotten into arguments with real people who were genuinely mad the bad guy had been killed and wanted to know why the cop/security guard/armed citizen didn't "just shoot the gun out of his hand".