Amy seems alright, still, the SCOTUS should be a reflection on America. We've already had plenty of Catholics, Scalia is clearly one of our best Justices ever and was Catholic, and Jews on the court. I think Amy went to Notre Dame some. Though Trey might not be right choice, perhaps some choice with an Evangelical background, same as Trey's, could be selected.
What's important though is how they vote, if Trey is a staunch conservative, that'll work.