General Category > Editorial/Opinion/Blogs

The High Price of Stale Grievances (Race Relations and the Double Standards that Create More Grievan

(1/1)

mountaineer:

--- Quote --- Published on June 5, 2018
The High Price of Stale Grievances
 by Coleman Hughes   

In the fall of 2016, I was hired to play in Rihanna’s back-up band at the MTV Video Music Awards. To my pleasant surprise, several of my friends had also gotten the call. We felt that this would be the gig of a lifetime: beautiful music, primetime TV, plus, if we were lucky, a chance to schmooze with celebrities backstage.

But as the date approached, I learned that one of my friends had been fired and replaced. The reason? He was a white Hispanic, and Rihanna’s artistic team had decided to go for an all-black aesthetic—aside from Rihanna’s steady guitarist, there would be no non-blacks on stage. Though I was disappointed on my friend’s behalf, I didn’t consider his firing as unjust at the time—and maybe it wasn’t. Is it unethical for an artist to curate the racial composition of a racially-themed performance? Perhaps; perhaps not. My personal bias leads me to favor artistic freedom, but as a society, we have yet to answer this question definitively.

One thing, however, is clear. If the races were reversed—if a black musician had been fired in order to achieve an all-white aesthetic—it would have made front page headlines. It would have been seen as an unambiguous moral infraction.   ...

Yet there we were—young black men born decades after anything that could rightly be called ‘oppression’ had ended—benefitting from a social license bequeathed to us by a history that we have only experienced through textbooks and folklore. And my white Hispanic friend (who could have had a tougher life than all of us, for all I know) paid the price. The underlying logic of using the past to justify racial double-standards in the present is rarely interrogated. What do slavery and Jim Crow have to do with modern-day blacks, who experienced neither?   ...
--- End quote ---
Lengthy but worthwhile read. Published at Quillette.

Oceander:
Wow.  He is a gifted author.  His writing is clear and forceful, even setting aside the subject matter. 

mountaineer:
Yes, a fine writer. Hard to believe he's only an undergraduate in college. His discussion of affirmative action in universities is rather sobering, too.

Navigation

[0] Message Index