Author Topic: Batteries perform many different functions on the power grid  (Read 1629 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline thackney

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12,267
  • Gender: Male
Batteries perform many different functions on the power grid
« on: January 08, 2018, 06:39:33 pm »
Batteries perform many different functions on the power grid
https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=34432
JANUARY 8, 2018



Driven largely by installations over the past three years, the electric power industry has installed about 700 megawatts (MW) of utility-scale batteries on the U.S. electric grid. As of October 2017, these batteries made up about 0.06% of U.S. utility-scale generating capacity. Another 22 MW of batteries are planned for the last two months of 2017, with 69 MW more planned for 2018.

New energy storage information available in the 2016 edition of EIA’s Annual Electric Generator Report provides more detail on battery capacity, charge and discharge rates, storage technology types, reactive power ratings, storage enclosure types, and expected usage applications.

Batteries, like other energy storage technologies, can serve as both energy suppliers and consumers at different times, creating an unusual combination of cost and revenue streams and making direct comparisons to other generation technologies challenging.

The decision to build a new power plant depends in part on its initial construction costs and ongoing operating costs. Although battery projects have a relatively low average construction cost, they are not stand-alone generation sources and must buy electricity supplied by other generators to charge and cover the round-trip efficiency losses experienced during cycles of charging and discharging.

Battery costs also depend on technical characteristics such as generating capability, which for energy storage systems can be described in two ways:

 * Power capacity or rating. Measured in megawatts, this is the maximum instantaneous amount of power that can be produced on a continuous basis and is the usual type of generator capacity discussed

 * Energy capacity. Measured in megawatthours (MWh), this is the total amount of energy that can be stored or discharged by the battery

A battery’s duration is the ratio of its energy capacity to its power capacity. For instance, a battery with a 2 MWh energy capacity and 1 MW power capacity can produce at its maximum power capacity for 2 hours. Actual operation of batteries can vary widely from these specifications. Batteries discharged at lower-than-maximum rates will yield longer duration times and possibly more energy capacity.

Short-duration batteries are designed to provide power for a very short time, usually on the order of minutes to an hour, and are generally less expensive per MW to build. Long-duration batteries can provide power for several hours and are more expensive per MW.

On the revenue side, batteries have relatively low capacity factors because of charging durations and cycling limitations for optimal performance. Nevertheless, they can uniquely capture a range of value streams, which can sometimes be combined to improve project economics. Some of the uses for batteries include:

* Balancing grid supply and demand.  Batteries can help balance electricity supply and demand on multiple time scales (by the second, minute, or hour).  Fast-ramping batteries are particularly well suited to provide ancillary grid services such as frequency regulation, which helps maintain the grid’s electric frequency on a second-to-second basis.

* Peak shaving and price arbitrage opportunities. By buying power and charging during lower-price (or negative-price) periods and selling power and discharging during higher-price periods, batteries can flatten daily load or net load shapes.  Shifting portions of electricity demand from peak hours to other times of day also reduces the amount of higher-cost, seldom-used generation capacity needed to be online, which can result in overall lower wholesale electricity prices.

* Storing and smoothing renewable generation. Storing excess solar- and wind-generated electricity and supplying it back to the grid or to local loads when needed can reduce renewable curtailments, negative wholesale power prices coincident with wind and solar over-generation, and price spikes related to evening peak ramping needs.  Co-locating batteries with solar and wind generators allows system owners to more predictably manage the power supplied to the grid by combined renewable-generator-and-battery systems.

* Deferring large infrastructure investments.  Local pockets of growing electricity demand sometimes require electric utilities to build expensive new grid infrastructure such as upgraded substations or additional distribution lines to handle the higher demand, which can cost upwards of tens of millions of dollars.  Installing batteries at strategic locations, at a much lower cost, enables utilities to manage growing demand while deferring large grid investments.

* Reducing end-use consumer demand charges. Large power consumers such as commercial and industrial facilities can reduce their electricity demand charges, which are generally based on the facilities’ highest observed rates of electricity consumption during peak periods, by using on-site energy storage during peak demand times.

* Back-up power. Batteries can provide back-up power to households, businesses, and distribution grids during outages or to support electric reliability.  As part of an advanced microgrid setup, batteries can help keep power flowing when the microgrid is islanded, or temporarily electrically separated, from the rest of the grid.

Life is fragile, handle with prayer

Offline IsailedawayfromFR

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 18,746
Re: Batteries perform many different functions on the power grid
« Reply #1 on: January 08, 2018, 08:16:23 pm »
Batteries perform many different functions on the power grid
https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=34432
JANUARY 8, 2018



Driven largely by installations over the past three years, the electric power industry has installed about 700 megawatts (MW) of utility-scale batteries on the U.S. electric grid. As of October 2017, these batteries made up about 0.06% of U.S. utility-scale generating capacity. Another 22 MW of batteries are planned for the last two months of 2017, with 69 MW more planned for 2018.

New energy storage information available in the 2016 edition of EIA’s Annual Electric Generator Report provides more detail on battery capacity, charge and discharge rates, storage technology types, reactive power ratings, storage enclosure types, and expected usage applications.

Batteries, like other energy storage technologies, can serve as both energy suppliers and consumers at different times, creating an unusual combination of cost and revenue streams and making direct comparisons to other generation technologies challenging.

The decision to build a new power plant depends in part on its initial construction costs and ongoing operating costs. Although battery projects have a relatively low average construction cost, they are not stand-alone generation sources and must buy electricity supplied by other generators to charge and cover the round-trip efficiency losses experienced during cycles of charging and discharging.

Battery costs also depend on technical characteristics such as generating capability, which for energy storage systems can be described in two ways:

 * Power capacity or rating. Measured in megawatts, this is the maximum instantaneous amount of power that can be produced on a continuous basis and is the usual type of generator capacity discussed

 * Energy capacity. Measured in megawatthours (MWh), this is the total amount of energy that can be stored or discharged by the battery

A battery’s duration is the ratio of its energy capacity to its power capacity. For instance, a battery with a 2 MWh energy capacity and 1 MW power capacity can produce at its maximum power capacity for 2 hours. Actual operation of batteries can vary widely from these specifications. Batteries discharged at lower-than-maximum rates will yield longer duration times and possibly more energy capacity.

Short-duration batteries are designed to provide power for a very short time, usually on the order of minutes to an hour, and are generally less expensive per MW to build. Long-duration batteries can provide power for several hours and are more expensive per MW.

On the revenue side, batteries have relatively low capacity factors because of charging durations and cycling limitations for optimal performance. Nevertheless, they can uniquely capture a range of value streams, which can sometimes be combined to improve project economics. Some of the uses for batteries include:

* Balancing grid supply and demand.  Batteries can help balance electricity supply and demand on multiple time scales (by the second, minute, or hour).  Fast-ramping batteries are particularly well suited to provide ancillary grid services such as frequency regulation, which helps maintain the grid’s electric frequency on a second-to-second basis.

* Peak shaving and price arbitrage opportunities. By buying power and charging during lower-price (or negative-price) periods and selling power and discharging during higher-price periods, batteries can flatten daily load or net load shapes.  Shifting portions of electricity demand from peak hours to other times of day also reduces the amount of higher-cost, seldom-used generation capacity needed to be online, which can result in overall lower wholesale electricity prices.

* Storing and smoothing renewable generation. Storing excess solar- and wind-generated electricity and supplying it back to the grid or to local loads when needed can reduce renewable curtailments, negative wholesale power prices coincident with wind and solar over-generation, and price spikes related to evening peak ramping needs.  Co-locating batteries with solar and wind generators allows system owners to more predictably manage the power supplied to the grid by combined renewable-generator-and-battery systems.

* Deferring large infrastructure investments.  Local pockets of growing electricity demand sometimes require electric utilities to build expensive new grid infrastructure such as upgraded substations or additional distribution lines to handle the higher demand, which can cost upwards of tens of millions of dollars.  Installing batteries at strategic locations, at a much lower cost, enables utilities to manage growing demand while deferring large grid investments.

* Reducing end-use consumer demand charges. Large power consumers such as commercial and industrial facilities can reduce their electricity demand charges, which are generally based on the facilities’ highest observed rates of electricity consumption during peak periods, by using on-site energy storage during peak demand times.

* Back-up power. Batteries can provide back-up power to households, businesses, and distribution grids during outages or to support electric reliability.  As part of an advanced microgrid setup, batteries can help keep power flowing when the microgrid is islanded, or temporarily electrically separated, from the rest of the grid.


Interesting read on batteries.

Here's a few Questions:

1. - I normally do not consider a battery being part of our generating capacity on the electric grid inasumuch as, by definition, they are not a net generator of electricity.  I do understand that at times they are a power user and other times a power supplier.  So the question is:  When I read of various power generating capacity of all types, solar, gas, nuclear, etc., is electric power via battery also invariably included?

2. Do we know capital costs per MW generated via battery vs other sources of power? I am curious how expensive it truly is to generate a MW via battery compared to say coal or gas.  How about operating expenses too?

3.  What is the life of a typical battery generating station?  10 years? 20 years?  Am guessing these batteries are more sophisticated and longer-lived than the simple ones I come in contact with that do not last more than 3 to five years.

4. How dangerous are they?  Do they explode if certain conditions occur as chemical batteries can do?

Am seeking your expertise to bring about some more understanding for me, the EE-challenged engineer.

@thackney



No punishment, in my opinion, is too great, for the man who can build his greatness upon his country's ruin~  George Washington

Offline thackney

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12,267
  • Gender: Male
Re: Batteries perform many different functions on the power grid
« Reply #2 on: January 08, 2018, 08:50:52 pm »
Interesting read on batteries.

Here's a few Questions:

1. - I normally do not consider a battery being part of our generating capacity on the electric grid inasumuch as, by definition, they are not a net generator of electricity.  I do understand that at times they are a power user and other times a power supplier.  So the question is:  When I read of various power generating capacity of all types, solar, gas, nuclear, etc., is electric power via battery also invariably included?

Keep in mind, Electrical Power System are sized for the peak load.  Those few hours determine the system build, even though the average power required is far less.  Battery systems are very new and quite rare in utility sized units, but growing.  A better comparison for them is hydro pumped storage.  These system economically don't compete with a base load plant, but the peakers that are very inefficient and run for a few hours.

Quote
2. Do we know capital costs per MW generated via battery vs other sources of power? I am curious how expensive it truly is to generate a MW via battery compared to say coal or gas.  How about operating expenses too?

I haven't seen and they are so new, and rapidly evolving, the data isn't very meaningful yet.

Quote
3.  What is the life of a typical battery generating station?  10 years? 20 years?  Am guessing these batteries are more sophisticated and longer-lived than the simple ones I come in contact with that do not last more than 3 to five years.

Sizing long life in battery systems is done by "overbuilding".  Just like in an electric car, the peak charge and minimum charge levels under operational controls are greatly limiting how much charge in and charge out of the system.  I do this in Uninterruptible Power Supply System that keep the essential control power up on process control in a refinery or chemical plant.  I can routinely get 25 year life out of those batteries.  But you would freak out at the cost per Amphour compared to something you put in car.

Quote
4. How dangerous are they?  Do they explode if certain conditions occur as chemical batteries can do?

The risk are there, but the operational limits for the long life greatly reduce these to almost not statistically significant.

Quote
Am seeking your expertise to bring about some more understanding for me, the EE-challenged engineer.

Cheers!
Life is fragile, handle with prayer

Offline IsailedawayfromFR

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 18,746
Re: Batteries perform many different functions on the power grid
« Reply #3 on: January 08, 2018, 10:20:19 pm »
Thanks.  So I read from you comments that battery generation may not be part of the quoted power generating capacity.  Does that also go for hydro-pumped storage?
No punishment, in my opinion, is too great, for the man who can build his greatness upon his country's ruin~  George Washington

Offline thackney

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 12,267
  • Gender: Male
Re: Batteries perform many different functions on the power grid
« Reply #4 on: January 09, 2018, 01:24:31 am »
Thanks.  So I read from you comments that battery generation may not be part of the quoted power generating capacity.  Does that also go for hydro-pumped storage?

I mean the opposite.  Pumped storage and the battery systems would be included.  Everything revolves around peak system capacity.  Not 24/7 output, but the peak output the system can deliver, for the duration of the peak.
Life is fragile, handle with prayer