In my defense, I never posted to Invar. I should know better. I was posting to people advocating a third party.
I know that frustration with our current crop of Republicans sometimes makes people want to cry out for something else. But I don't think a third party is the answer.
If there were enough conservatives to make a "conservative" party the largest of the three (meaning more than 33% support of the electorate), then there would certainly be enough to be a
majority within the 45-50% or so of the electorate that votes Republican. It wouldn't take more than 25% of the total electorate (and that's on the high side) to seize conservative control of the GOP.
The problem isn't the GOP as a party. It is the lack of enough conservative
voters to elect conservatives in the GOP primary. And you don't solve the lack of conservative voters by breaking off into a fringe party that can't possibly win the 35%+ it would take to win national elections.
The math says the best conservative path to power - even if it is a slim one - is within the GOP.
@Emjay