Tough issues. First gulf war I still think was a success because of the coalition that was built and the objective of removing Iraq from Kuwait was accomplished along with no-fly zones meant to diminish Iraq power. Second gulf war has to be seen through the prism of 9-11 and the intel that was available at the time. Mistakes were made, but when Bush left office Iraq had stability after the surge of troops. Obama messed that all up with his dealings with the Iraqi leadership and Iraqi military creating a vacuum for ISUS and other terror groups to fill. I agree that Bush made mistakes in second gulf war, but hindsight in war is never the same as real time data and decision making. And waterboarding was NOT a mistake. Also, the results of the second gulf war and the Arab spring does cause one to rethink about our involvement in ME without truly understanding all the different alliances and rivalries. It has been, is and probably will be for decades to come one messed up part of the world and a boiling pot spewing out terrorists to endanger the world. Honestly Happy2BME this is a tough issue for me to understand and I am probably totally wrong in my views.
=========================================
Where to start?
I was in Desert Storm, and traveled all over Saudi Arabia. Didn't go into Kuwait. The Saudis (at that time) treated us like Royalty (because we were fighting THEIR war FOR them). Desert Storm was much different than 'Iraqi Freedom' in that it was completely clear to the world WHO the aggressor was (Iraq for invading Kuwait) and WHY the war was fought. At THAT point, the USA still had 'the high moral ground' in world opinion and had done 'the right thing.'
Fast forward to Iraqi Freedom, and the scenario is much foggier, much more controversial, and NOT clearly justified (WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION was almost the sole justification) in world opinion. Bush had to beg 'allies' to join in the coalition to invade Iraq. It is well documented that the majority of the Joint Chief's of Staff advised Bush NOT to invade Iraq, and that is where it started. No WMD was EVER found. It was complete bull$hit. And the rest is history.
My own son spent THREE YEARS in Iraq and came back and told me: "What Iraq really needs is another Saddam Hussein." He saw clearly, on the ground, up close and personal how the US invasion of Iraq had caused COMPLETE chaos not just in Iraq, but in the entire global region of the Middle East. He was not justifying Saddam's methods, but clearly pointing out that PRIOR TO Iraqi Freedom the region at least had SOME stability and was not in COMPLETE chaos and mayhem that really DID threaten the stability of the ENTIRE WORLD, thanks to the invasion of Iraq.
In retrospect, nobody in their right mind can dispute this.