Author Topic: Foolish "Intellectuals"  (Read 560 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline DeerSlayer

  • Hero Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 28
Foolish "Intellectuals"
« on: November 06, 2012, 11:07:27 PM »
I begin with Isaac Asimov, the late, famous, and formerly wealthy science fiction writer.   Many of his follies have escaped the notice of millions of his fans.  For example, Asimov was a famous atheist, and an exceedingly hateful one at that.  But why?

Did you know that Isaac himself claimed his atheism began after he prayed to God to pass a science test and when he failed, he renounced God for the remainder of his life.  God did not rise to Asimov's demands, and therefore God had to go.  Brilliant, no?

Atheism aside, Isaac was afraid to fly.  He only drove or rode on ground transportation, purely out of ignorance.  Flying commercially is ten times safer, mile for mile, than driving.

Atheism and ignorance aside, Asimov was a horrible husband and father. He closeted himself in his study with his typewriter, the better to connect with his adoring fans who rewarded him with fame and fortune.  Meanwhile his son suffered, without a father.  Asimov's son was later arrested when child porn was discovered on his personal computer.

For most decent humans, being a good parent is the most important part of their lives.  What good is wealth or fame if you can't love and cherish those who are most dependent on you.

Now let's examine Isaac Asimov's published stupidity.

". . . there is an object a mile above the surface of the earth that is moving upward
at a constant speed. We can tell when it started its journey . . . there is nothing in the upward
direction to stop, we could conclude that it would travel forever and its journey would have no
end." - Counting the Eons, page 150

Well, no it won't "travel forever."  There is the earth's gravity, which is substantial, and then there is
air resistance. Other than those.....

"If the tube (used to breath through when underwater)  is long enough and wide
enough, all the exhaled air remains in that long tube and you will breathe the same air over
and over again and it will not be long before you suffocate". - page 12

Ignorance waving a science book.  Isaac did not understand a couple of things wrong with his remarks.
First, when your chest is a mere four feet underwater, the pressure is so great that you cannot inhale.
I've tried to do it by extending a flexible snorkel, long before I read Counting the Eons.

But even if you could inhale at considerable depth, Isaac was still wrong.  You can exhale through your nose,
and inhale continuously fresh air through the snorkel.  It's quite elementary.

"We don't feel pressure of the weight of the atmosphere...the body's liquid contents
press outward..." - page 2

No the body's liquid contents don't "press outward."  You're simply quite incompressible, aside from the air in your lungs.

Next, Carl Sagan.

Offline DeerSlayer

  • Hero Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 28
Re: Foolish "Intellectuals"
« Reply #1 on: November 07, 2012, 03:22:03 AM »
Carl Sagan was a hypocrite of a very high order, perhaps not quite as high as Al Gore or Barack Obama, but up there nonetheless.
Sagan proselytized against overpopulation while having five children of his own.
Sagan proselytized on behalf of global warming while flying and driving everywhere, such was his own great importance.
Sagan claimed that commercial television was ignorant and a waste of time, so naturally he appeared often on.... commercial television.

Carl Sagan was a devout agnostic, in his own way of thinking.  This allowed him the intellectual argument of saying there might be a God, he just couldn't make up his own mind, one way or the other.  In fact, Sagan continued to propound arguments no different from atheists.  Ironically, Sagan's memorial service was held in St. John the Divine Roman Catholic Church in New York City.

Now, some of Sagan's more outrageous and anti-scientific comments from his books.

“Human beings, born ultimately of the stars and now for a while inhabiting a world called Earth, have begun their long voyage home.”  - Cosmos, page 12

Sorry, but humans aren't going anywhere.  It took Voyager 11 years to get to Jupiter.  That's a lot of oxygen and cheeseburgers.
So we speed up by a factor of 10.  Still a lot of oxygen and cheeseburgers and nowhere to refuel in space.

“Cosmos” is a Greek word for the order of the universe.  It implies the deep interconnectedness of all things.”  - page 18

In Pale Blue Dot, Sagan claimed that the universe shows "much poor planning."  This is the exact opposite of "deep interconnectedness of all things."  Sagan never had any problem contradicting himself, with a smile.

“Intellectual capacity is no guarantee against being dead wrong.”  - page 20

Tell that to any liberal professor, or to the massively intellectual Oceander - as he describes himself.

“What a marvelous cooperative arrangement - plants and animals each inhaling each other’s exhalations....” - page 33

There is "much poor planning" in the universe.  Pale Blue Dot, page 57

“Astronomical spectroscopy is an almost magical technique.  It amazes me still.” - page 93

More of that "poor planning" perhaps.

(Voyager 2 showed that) “Mars was a place.”  - page 121

Deep science - "Mars was a place."  College students might even understand this, the placeness of Mars.  Certainly Oceander would.

“There are limits to what we can do.” - page 124

"We can be fooled." - page 125

Noooo!  Really?  Carl Sagan, fooled?  You mean the guy who predicted that fires in the Gulf War would cause massive global cooling, and might never be put out?  The teacher who lamented widespread ignorance, for which teachers must bear a large measure of responsibility?

"We are ready at last to set sail for the stars.”  - page 193

Oh yeah.  "Ready."  Sagan spoke about nuclear blasts powering our space ships.  How's that going?  Only four light years to the second closest star, after our own sun.  Let's see,  669,600,00 mph, the speed of light, divided by ~30,000 mph works out to about 23,000.  That number times four years to get there. Bring a fishing pole. There may be some nice bass in the lakes.  I mean, if there are any lakes, that is.... on the earth-sized planet circling Alpha Centauri B.

“If we wished we could build Orion now.” - page 206

Orion is the space ship powered by external nuclear explosions. We could build that right now, dontcha know.  Challenger might have blown up, but hey.....

“A star twenty times the mass of the Sun will shrink . . . slip through a self-generated crack in the space-time continuum and vanish from our universe.”  - page 241

"Self-generated crack... in the space-time continuum..... "  vanishing to where, exactly?

“If we must worship a power greater than ourselves, does it not make sense to revere the Sun and stars?”  - page 243

Don't revere God.  Revere the Sun and the stars.  Like the cavemen must have done.  Brilliant, Carl.  Brilliant.

His follies continue, in book after book, and made him exceedingly wealthy.  That's why he smiled at you.

« Last Edit: November 07, 2012, 11:32:02 AM by DeerSlayer »

Share me

Digg  Facebook  SlashDot  Delicious  Technorati  Twitter  Google  Yahoo