Tylenol is poison, it makes everything worse, while ruining your liver. Do it a favor and drink Scotch, it's better than Tylenol (or less worse). I'm serious.
Every drug, prescription or non-prescription, is to some extent a poison. Even vitamins and herbal supplements can have risks.
Unfortunately, I can't take regular aspirin -- wreaks havoc with my digestive system. And ibuprofen and naproxin clash with meds I already take or they are risky for certain health conditions.
That said, when it comes to ordinary pain like a headache, I try to emulate my grandmother. She never took medication for anything. If she had a headache, she would just lie down till it was over.
She lived to be 90, so maybe she was on to something there.