He gets a "C" from me. He's not failing, but he's also not succeeding yet.
Gorsuch looks good, but the healthcare R&R was a debacle by any sane measure. And no, Trumperinos (another for truth_seeker's list), it was not the fault of the Freedom Caucus. That bill was bad, bad, bad. I read it and posted how bad it was within 2 hours of its release.
Trump's willingness to hitch his wagon to such a ridiculous bill goes to show how little he understands about real reform.
His travel ban is a media circus, almost exclusively negative for him. He fails to use the bully pulpit properly. Twitter is not a bully pulpit.
Kudos on the pipeline. Kudos on telling NATO nations to start paying their fair share. Kudos on telling the UN to go pound sand. Kudos on rolling back EPA regs for the coal industry.
But he's still stepping in it regularly. He submits a "better" budget, but could have REALLY rocked the world by saying, "And, I've told all my department heads that if they want to be included in next year's budget proposal, they will zero-base their requests, and we will be publishing it all online for the American people to review. Failure to zero-base will result in a 10% cut. Period. Get to work."